I like it. She is so beautiful!
But she needs to bleach her teeth.

she looks like kylie

This woman seems so comfortable in her own skin, I think she can pull off anything!

that liner looks
great on her....
i love her she's always
so bold on her looks

I like the eyes, sort of, but I don't like that color on her lips. I think it's too peach, she should of gone with more of a matte pink tone.

She is so hot!!!
She looks wonderful here!

I agree with wicked_lady....

I love this! I think she looks great...everything about it.

This look is really pretty, and really different for her. I like it on her.

BUT... her teeth look yellow. The lip color exaggerates it. Reconsider the lips, that's all I'm saying.

She looks so pretty here!

I like the eyes. The lips are a bit ... I dunno, too orange? There's something off about them.

beautiful! It's great when celebrities switch up their style!

wow! that looks awesome!!

Her eyes kind of make her look like Avril Lavigne. Personally, I hate it.

when you're that drop dead gorgeous and have the bone structure of her... aMAzing! and the makeup just emphasizes this even more! love it!

I think it's a gorgeous look. Not a fan of hers, but have to give her prop's. I do a subtler cat because I like how it lifts the eyes. If I'd change anything, it would be her hair...give it a little nourishment, it looks thirsty.

i agree w/ some other people - the eyes look good, but not a huge fan of the lip color.

She looks good!

I love it, I think it's very old school glamour, sort of a Sophia Loren look. I think it's great for special occasions! Not so excited about the lip color though.

Can someone please teach me how to get my eyes to look like that?

It's fabulous.

I think she looks better with a more natural look, but she does look undeniably hot!

very Bridgette Bardot

I love it!

Wow.
Totally balances out with her lips.
I love it!

She can pull off ANY look. She's SOOOO stunning!

Um Bellasugr, I think you're mistaken. That's 38-year-old Cate Blanchett...right?

Fabulous!

I think it works, plus with her hair looking strawberry blond she almost looks a bit like a Sixteen Candles Molly Ringwald!

she looks great, and i am so-so about her

I am generally really not a fan of very dark eye makeup on very fair and fair-haired girls--it tends to look trashy to me --but on her it looks all right. I think because it isn't smudged too far out on her upper and lower lids, and the rest of her makeup is very clean and fresh. And I am feeling the cat's eye thing. What a pretty girl.

scarlett johansson is always beautiful, i think on most people this would look tres terrible!

I think she looks good no matter what she wears / how she makes up

She looks pretty, but some of the other users are right; that lip color is a little off. Maybe it should have been closer to what she's wearing? I mean, almost-purple and orange-y aren't the worst possible match, but in this case, they do NOT go well together.

But yes, she's a really beautiful young lady.

Scarlett is so gorgeous she doesn't need to be wearing all that makeup!

i dotn like her but i do like her make up

It looks fantastic...obviously not an every day look or something I would try to pull off, but it looks very cool. Oh and I don't like her either!

The eyes look great.........She looks better with a stronger eye and lighter lip color than the red lips/natural eye. A cooler tone lip color would have helped with the teeth issue.

I love it. It's ideal for the nighttime. I hate when celebs wear wayyyyy too much eyeliner in the daytime. It's too much. But she looks good wit it.

P.S. I sometimes forget she's 23! She acts older.

I absolutely love it!!!! Very sultry. If only I had the guts & steady hands to pull that off!

Eyes like that look best on brunettes.

I thought the dark lips and eyes on the W cover was a little too harsh. But with paler lips and dark eyes she looks sultry. I also love her pale skin.

I love it. She is so pretty its nice to see girls that arent super super thin it disgusts me.

woww she looks gorgeous here I usually don't find her pretty..something is off about her but here the whole look is beautiful!

Love her... so gorgeous.

She's too fair for that look!

so so SO on point, scarlett. i agree that i usually hate dark & heavy eye make-up on girls with such fair features, but SHE looks so glam!

she looks ugly

I love it! It makes her look so different from her usual self. I had to do a double take to make sure it was her. Usually she puts a lot of attention on her pouty lips (which is getting so old), so this is a nice change.

she looks like avril, and it`s not a good thing.