I JUST bought this product and have only used it once, but I think it's really pretty! I own a couple of other Almay eyeliners, and I find that they last for a fairly long time. This one seems to be no different. I bought this because it reminded me of these eyeliners that Almay used to make a few years ago (and unfortunately stopped making). I think the line was also called Bright Eyes or something similar. But they were dual-ended liners like this (with two coordinating shades), although they were automatic pencils. When I saw this new line, I was thrilled because I really loved the old liners and assumed these would be similar.

And so far, I'm pleased...the black shade provides definition to my eyes and the champagne shade highlights and illuminates. I think I'll be using it on a fairly regular basis. I might even have to pick up another shade!

I really like Almay liners. They do not irritate my eyes (contacts..) and they stay on relatively well. I also liked the bright eyes line, but these are very good also and the dual ended application is really cool because you are getting two in 1 which for eyeliners is good, shampoo & conditioners, not so much.