Out of curiosity, I asked you to share your opinions of Maybelline Great Lash mascara. It's never been my favorite, but it's a perennial best-seller. Over in the land of Product Reviews [1], opinion is split directly down the middle, earning this mascara an average rating. I loved reading everybody's opinions, but these three reviews really stood out:

• The Italian Jem [2]: "I find Maybelline Great Lash Royal Blue to be a very fun color, and cheaper than any other blue mascara. ... Putting the blue Great Lash over a single coat of a well-loved black mascara can help the lashes look fuller."
• Coachluvr33 [3]: "I don't see it. I don't get it. What is the fuss surrounding this cult classic mascara? It produced clumpy, dense, spider-like creations on my eyelids that were hardly attractive and a real pain to get rid of."
• Fab_domini [4]: "I love this mascara. It might not live up to all the hype because it doesn't do anything out of this world, but its enough for a natural look."

Thanks to everyone who shared opinions! Thanks, too, to these three readers — check your inboxes for a Sugar gift! If you'd like to check out our preview of product reviews, have a little poke around the place [5].