The start of the crimp is wayyy obvious on Madonna. Crimps seem to add 20 years to Lindsay Lohan. The crimped look is DATED!

Perhaps when Madonna got her hair done she should have had her roots dyed too? yuck

There is something very bad 80's about both styles. Tacky even

I like Lindsay's, it looks beachy. Madonna needs to do some root touch up.

Lindsay's is cute.
Madonna looks well, like Madge...

I think they both look ick. Madonna's roots are not flattering and LL hair looks greasy.

I have a crimper like this and I know how hard it is to make crimped hair look pretty. nice try lindsey, but madonna wins hands down.

I think it's a bit more flattering on Madonna, but I could live without the look on either.

Definitely Madonna, but I don't think it's all that flattering on either of them.

I just chose Lindsay over Madonna....oh gees...

I kind of like this look. I chose Madonna.

I'm not a big LL fan, but Madonna's look is hideous. Perhaps it's the roots.

My hair usually looks sort of like lindsay's only messier, and less fake looking. I don't think its a good look on either one.

I don't really like it on either of them.

Rachel Ray started and rocks this look better than either of those two... I voted for madonna for the sheer fact that hear hair doesn't look like an oil slick.

I meant Rachel Zoe wow i need to go to sleep asap!

Madonna, I'd like to introduce you to Lindsay. She's in her 20's.

Need I say more?

If I had to choose I would choose Lindsay's.

Neither. Why does Madonna never change her hair anymore? It's been the same for years now - parted in the middle, either curly or fuzzy waves, dark roots and this unbecoming brassy medium blonde. What happened to her cutting edge looks? She's not too old to still play around.

^I should add it looks like she lightened her hair a little, but it's still not becoming. She could use to take a lesson from her friend Gwyneth. Her hair always looks fresh and clean.

i like, both are very special characters.hugs for you,ledi.

I voted for Lindsay, but I actually love the look on both of them. So Carrie Bradshaw season two. Bella, do you know how to create a similar look?

I see Lindsays roots too. I voted for Madonna because she has been rocking the style since Lindsay was a fetus. La Hohan should stick to stick straight hair.

I chose Lindsey (and I don't even like her) but I chose her over Madge because Madonna's roots are too dark and obvious

I liek Londsey's because they're not too perfect...

I think both are cute but a little bit better due to youth on Lindsay.

I read that they used the same hairstylist that night.

I think it looks bad on both, too fake on Madonna and it makes LL look older. I don't particulary like this look but

eghk- i seriously dislike this hair style

They both look awful. Madonna looks really old too.

Madonna! with less eyeliner, though...

Geez lindsey looks like she has dirt smeared on her all the time...not cute and her eyebrows make her look angry and grumpy...soften them up girl

Lindsay looks beachy and more natural.

I don't know, i can't really focus on the hair because lindsay looks dirty and madonna looks like she's on crack!

Lilo's looks more natural...

and as I'm typing this, I'm noticing that like a lot of other people said that too...

Ulgh, both look scary. Just in time for Halloween.

I don't really like either...

Maddona wins totally hands down..... The crimp style was in during the early 90's, and IT'S BAAAAAACK!