I think that's just the wrong shade of pink.

the red looks sooo much better...

Yeah, that's not a very flattering pink on her. She looks great in the red.

I think the red looks really horrible.

wow I don't think I've seen red pulled off any better.. she looks awesome in red!!! Not saying she could look better in a diff one than the left... but I love red on her!

RED! She makes a girl who never wears lipstick want to rock some red! With her dark hair and nice lips it just looks great. The pink looks fine but I feel like it washes her out. I guess it depends on the look you want but the red just suits her features the best.

it's not just the red lipstick i like better, it's her eyes. her makeup is just way overdone in the pic with the pink lipstick.

She rocks the red!

Neither. I thinks she looks better in her signature nude lipsticks.

I like her with the neutral eye and the red lips. The eye makeup with the pink lips is overwhelming, and the pink is the wrong color on her.

i've never seen her with red lipstick before. i think she looks stunning!

She needs to keep her make-up minimal. She looks much less trashy and pretty.

So, red most definitely.

I really like the red. She looks so pretty and not trashy at all.

Agreed brittanyk, I really like her eye makeup with the red lipstick. She has beautiful eyes but she wears too much makeup and hides them. And the red is awesome!!

I voted for red but I think the picture of her wearing pink is an awkward photo too

She would look amazing in hot pink. The red is too much and the pink is too close to her skin color.

Red! I've seen her wearing pink before and I don't think this is just a bad shade; pink in general is not too good for her. I think her yellow undertones, nice sharp features and inherent sex-appeal really make her rock the red.

The red looks fab on her!

I agree that the red is SO much nicer.

the red makes her look so hot

Would love to know what brand and color lipstick and blush she's wearing in the red lips pic! She looks amazing!

wtf is up with her eyebrows??
that's all i can stare at.
they look wonky.

Personally, how about something in the middle. The pink was too light and the red was too bright.

i think she would look better in a more natural lip color, so i voted for the pink even though i agree that in the picture, the lipstick is too close to her skin color. she does pull off the red lip well though i think she's so sexy and gorgeous, albeit slightly trashy

i think she looks more sophisticated in the red and the nude makes her look bland

I am more used to seeing her how she is in the first pic. I don't mind the rest of the make-up (not for every day, obvs), but I don't like the lips. I like the red lip color and the make-up in that whole look...it makes her look like two totally different people! I feel inspired to try out some reddish lips and lash action myself.

I have never seen her with a red lip color, and I think it looks awesome on her!

I don't care for her, but I like how she only played up one feature at a time. I think I chose the red, because she played up her eyes less, and it made her look more elegant and exotic. I think the pink lipstick and raccoon eyes make her look like a kid who got in her mother's makeup case. The pink is just too frosted for her complexion.

She looks very natural in the red, so that's unique. My mom has very similar coloring and always pulled of red well.

She looks way better in the red, since she has pretty-shaped lips.

I want to smack her with a box of tissues and a bottle of makeup remover. Too much, always too much!

she looks so elegant in the red lipstick!

I think she looks pretty in the red and in the pink, as well

I think she looks gorgeous with either!

she looks good in both, because her eyeshadow colors complement the lip colors she used.

in this case, she looks pretty in the red lips, because it is a new look from her, which she can carry off well. we are so used to, and perhaps tired of her smokey/nude combo.

i think she looks pretty in this red lip look, though i am not a fan of her.

loove looove loooooove the red!!! I only wish I could carry it off!

The red looks so much prettier. And it's weird b/c with the red, I feel like I can take her seriously...she looks mature.

I'm not really feeling either color. And what's up with the look on her face in both pictures?

She's really gorgeous regardless, but her makeup is a bit much, even for her, in the first pic. I had no idea she could look so ladylike (in a good way) and so much less Playboy Bunnyfied as she does in the second pic.

I actually like the pink better--the red makes her lips too overwhelming for my taste.

Is it just me, or has she also gotten better about not applying her makeup with a damn spatula?

Definitely the red, everything about her look in that picture is gorgeous. The pink looks a little porn star-ish.

i hate the red on her. i think red lipstick is an older shade and is best on more mature ladies and women. The pink is nicer but its not that great either. I love nude shades on women more so than bright red lipstick

I'm not into red lipstick much but really love that particular shade she's wearing. Both colors are nice but with her skin tone that red is absolutely perfect.

i don't like how much eye makeup she always has on!! the toned down eyes and red lips give her a fresh look...

She looks stunning in both! I love her makeup... she has a really good make up artist... I just wish her eye brows weren't so close in the middle... they should be shortened a tad to fit her face better...

I guess I'm in the minority here but I like the pink. I think the red lips makes her look older. Maybe it's the hairstyle as well?

I've always seen her pictures where she had dark eyes and pale lips. It's about time that Kim changed her look with red lipstick.