I never ever liked Kate in that add.

Although I think Kate's face is ruined otherwise, here in this ad I actually think Kate's face is more sophisticated than Keira's.

Kate looks more mature and elegant, whereas Keira is a bit too thin and girly (imo) to do an ad for such a perfume. She would be perfect as a Calvin Klein girl though.

I love how Kate looks like a sophisticated version of
Alex De Large from A Clockwork Orange(is it just me?),so yeah I prefer Kate's ad by far.In fact, I can't believe Chanel would choose anyone as "plain" as Keira over quirky Kate.

Anyone but Kate. I am so tired of her...I never understood the obsession with her.

keira

There's something about Keira's mouth that really irritates me. Then again there is even more about Kate that irritates me. So neither I guess.

not really bothered with either of them!

I agree that Keira doesn't look sophistocated enough to be the model for Coco Mademoiselle. While it is supposedly a more youthful fragrance, I still don't think she fits the bill. That isn't to say I'm particularly fond of Kate otherwise, but I think she's the better model in this instance.

Quite honestly, I don't think either of them have the kind of sophistication one typically associates with Chanel.

Neither.

Kate , u can hate her but we have to admit it that as a model she's one of the best...she can make even a sack look good

I don't like Kate much, but in these adds she looks heaps better than keira...She looks sickly in this .

Keira looks like she doesn't know what pose she's supposed to be in..

Keira all the way.

kate moss forever. she's wonderful.

Kate is a professional well-known model for a reason. Of the two, as much as I adore Kiera, I think Kate is a stronger model.

I'm not a big fan of Kate Moss... but she's definitely Coco Mademoiselle. Keira might be a good actress but she's definitely losing to Kate in modelling.

im so over kate...keira's isn't that great, but anyone can do better than kate.

i agree- dont normally like kate, but looks good here.

Not a fan of Kate, but she looks good here.

Keira looks just to skinny in the ad!

While I prefer the classic Kate Moss, I understand that for an updated look for the ads Kiera is an excellent choice.

kate looks fantastic in the pic, keira would make a good model tho

I love them both... they represent absolute beauty for me!

I voted Kate, Kiera has an odd look to me.

Yeah, I'm doubtful either of them are Chanel material, but between the ads, I really don't like Keira's. It was a bad styling choice because she doesn't look sensual or sexy at all with the hat covering her flat chest. She's thin, but don't emphasize it so much.

Kate all the way.

Ideally I'd prefer Vanessa Paradis for all Chanel perfumes, but of the two people given as options I think Kate seems better suited for this than Kiera.

I never in a 100 years expected to like Kate Moss, and even less to think that she looked healthier than another model... but I'm afraid that she does look healthier here! Yikes what's the world coming to.

Kate. Her ad have seem a lot more professional (I know it's her job) and sophisticated, very fitting with the perfume. But Keira's is a little 'blah', it hasn't got the 'wow factor'.

I like Keira. I think Kate is a bad role model

I voted Keira only because I really dislike Kate Moss.

I like keira, her pose is sexier.

I like Kate here much better, although I like Keira as an actress very much. Actually, I wanted to have the perfume, because of this ad, but it doesn't smell very good on me, too soapy

I think Keira is very attractive. I'm tired of Kate Moss.

it's an unfair game : keira picture is so dark, and not as good as the photographers that take the moss picture! but keira is pretty, while kate is not. keira is young while kate is not and i'm soo booored of kate moss uggly face
she is so retouched here, you can't recognize her face
SO KEIRA

oh man. i love them both!!
but i still kinda think keira should stay on the screens. kate has this nice face but not so pretty that you almost ahte her, if that makes sense

Marilyn Monroe was Chanel, neither of these girls say Chanel to me. Nicole Kidman was a good choice too. Kate is odd, and Keira looks like a dirty magician. I could also see them both doing Calvin Klein or something, but there isn't a sense of sophistication about them.

kate just fits in well with the mysterious look of chanel (whats so mysterious about it, who knows)

i like keira. i know im going to be stoned for this but i dont see the attraction to kate moss and i never have. a bit overrated imo.

I don't like either in the ads. kate's a little better but i like keira as a person better, although she look sa bit scary

I completely agree Junebrug!
Yeah, Marilyn Monroe was Channel, but as far as modern models go, I'll have to say Nicole did a better job than these two.

So sick of Kate!

Channel is meant to be classic/classy. There isn't much classy about coke binges. Keira would win out of the two, but I'm not a fan of the layout.

I'm not a fan of either, but if I had to choose, I would choose Keira over Kate, for sure!

They both look emaciated. Gross.

Keira looks a lot like Shalom Harlow in her early stages, she is just sooooo plain and tooo skinny. I ll always go for Kate... she has that dirty side, that exudes perfection!!!! LOVE KATE MOSS!

And its my perfume!!!!!

I thought (once again) it was Natalie Portman on the left, so I was like "Cool! I'm gonna vote for her!"...

But then I realized, so I voted "neither".