light pink of course. The red lipstick makes her look old!

ditto! the pink makes her look still very youthful!

I LOVE LL!

Her lips are screwed up either way, but the natural color makes it less noticeable.

I like the light pink better, the red kind of makes her look like a hooker.

She's a wreck, period... but pale pink definitely.

i think she needs to make it more pinker but not RED

light pink for sure.

Light pink looks much better on her.

That red is horrid.

she looked like a clown with the bright red lipstick. didn't pair well with her complexion, hair and other makeup. sickkk.

those red lips were ridiculous

She's a hot mess so I can't accurately say which looks better.

What are you doing BellaSugar? First, you make me choose between what looks best on Fergie, and then you pick another haggard mess to feature!
Lindsay looks completely vacant in both pictures-- her hair looks over processed and her skin is some unnatural color. Anyway, she should stick with the girly pink, because homegirl doesn't need anything else to make her look older than she is!

I'd prefer if she did something about her eyebrows. I think they grown a bit wild... Just me?

you are supposed to cjoose one. when you have that heavy eyeliner and bright lipstick you look like a street walker. the only time they are ok is the midnight show.

I agree with gibbon, i don't think she can't pull off red lipstick, but if she wanted to wear it she should have gotten rid of all the self-tanner and the heavy mascara.

lol isnt that the point? they WANT to look hella fake, with their fake bake, overprocessed hair, heavy makeup...that and they probably think its covers up their cracked-out face? nonetheless, i cant imagine her looking any worse than with the red lipstick.

I don't expect her to be around much longer--very sad!

I always seem to pick the lighter colours.

the light pink..the red is really too severe

The red lips remind me of her awful chanel throw together of an outfit she put together for the cruise. Trashorific.

pink, looks so much better!

There's very few people who i think can pull of that bright red successfully (christina aguilera being one of them)... i think LL should stay with the light hues.

bellasugar, i hope youre reading this! im tired of you posting trashy ugly ass women in your "beauty" section. you make us pick between fergie (nothing can ever make that manly bizzzatch pretty. ever.), an orange-abused jessica (NEVER glitzy, that butchers the word), and a cracked out lindsay lohan. i mean, "lilo." all i'm waiting for is for you to post something on pamela anderson. i'm starting to wonder if hollywood just like trashy women?

Light pink!
Red doesnt go with her annoying bright orange skin.

Absolutely both!

Neither one.She looks awful, Period!

as long as it isn't all smudgy like the fuscia garbage she wore the other night lol

You should have done "Which skin color do you prefer"- that first one, yikes! As a red head she would look so much better with her natural fair complexion.

eh. I could take either or leave either.

Light pink is better. Red lips doesn´t look good on everybody.

Doesn't matter- she needs to eat a mayonnaise sandwich...

I don;t mind either, but I guess the pink is best.

red doesn't suit her.

her pic with the neutral pink is a way better one, but if the other one was a better picture i dont think shed look to bad in either.

If she wasn't roadworker orange, she might look alright in red. Until then, she looks wierd!

Pink-red looks bad with her skin plus she doesn't need a bold lip when she's got that much dark eyeliner on.

i dislike the red, but the light pink makes her lips look almost nude. maybe something in between would be more flattering?

I love Lindsay

I reckon the natural...

Red doesn't seem to suit many people, so far (since the recent trend) the only new people i've seen wearing that looked hot was Elisha Cuthbert and Ali Larter looks ok as well..

Everyone else not so hot.

I think she looks great in both but the red is a little too bold for such a casual look. I think that the best red is super glossy and she went for that.

her mouth freaks me out. i think it's 'cause i confuse myself counting all of the STD's it holds.

I don't like either one. I would perfer a russet color due to her coloring. Those colors just aren't right for her. I think the pale color was trying to balance the highlights in the hair.

Prety light pink. I love nude lips...

the pale pink makes her look like she is dehydrated. She needs a happy medium between bold res, and too pale pink.