Nothing wrong with some guy liner in my opinion, as a girl who likes the edgy/rocker boys it works for me. No average guys for this girl!!

What about Brandon Flowers?! Best guy makeup imo!

Ewan McGregor has worn eyeliner in the past... and I think he looks pretty hot with it.

Advah, I totally agree!

This slideshow made my morning!

Ugh, guy-liner is a total turnoff to me.

I'm definitely not into guy-liner, but I do love me some Brandon Flowers! When my husband is sporting short hair, he sort of looks like him, YUM!

I wouldn't want to be in the company of any of these dudes.

If it makes them feel better about themselves, then a little make up is fine!

Nice slideshow!

billie joe armstrong looks good with eyeliner on.

I think that it is freaky and I think that a man wearing makeup is just to feminine to me. Plus, Zac Efron is a little hottie. I just had to say that. Sorry for getting off the topic.

The once instance of guyliner working for me is Johnny Depp in Pirates

I'm all for men wearing makeup. People should do what makes them happy and to say otherwise IMO is as backwards as saying pants are for men.

LoL, I always try to convince my boyfriend to let me put mascara on his eyelashes b/c I want to see how long they look with mascara on. But he always gets so mad at me for even mentioning it.

I'm not really sure about the whole men wearing makeup, though. It just seems odd.

What about Daniel Johns? He always looks hot in eyeliner.

It depends on the guy... Some really know how to rock it (Johnny Depp, Brandon Flowers) and some look like they're trying too hard (Pete Wentz, The guys from Good Charlotte).

Now I have REM's song "Crush in Eyeliner" in my head I've loved guys in eyeliner since the 80s. The Cure, anyone?

totally agree with a million suns, the only guy-liner that i like to see is on Johnny Depp in Pirates, too sexy! that man can do anything and i'd still love him!

No guyliner for me thanks. Aside from David Bowie, all the other guys are trying to hard. And Boy George is just Boy George. He doesn't count...

jared has pretty eyes

i just never condone guy liner

i have lusted over men in eyeliner ever since I can remember! Maybe it started with Robert Smith!?! If done right...ooh...there can be nothing sexier!!

most of them wouldn't even hide the fact that they wear makeup...they do it as part of their "look" but ZAC EFRON kills me every time! does he not know we can see all that makeup? jesse mcartney should have also made the list...we know you wear foundation to cover your acne! it doesn't look good!

guy-liner...guy-liner....ehh maybe for some celebrities they can get away with it, but i don't think i would be likely to find the guy in school with the eyeliner cute, its kinda creepy.

Eyeliner and mascara on guys is really hot. Well on emo guys at least. I convinced my boyfriend to put on eyeliner before and it was really sexy. Any make up other than eye stuff on guys is... Eh... Not against it but not for it. I really don't care. Lolz. But my boyfriend is willing to put on eyeliner for me because he knows I think it's sexy and knows it's a major turn on for me. Lolz. He's terrible at it, but i promised him i'd help him. Lolz. But guys in eye make up. Damn that's HOT.

its good for the cause of emancipation that men wear make-up. it can look very good too. you can even look macho with it, (johnnie Depp) or feminin/beautiful if you like. Make this world beautiful. Make yourself beautiful. Sometimes it can give you self esteem as well. It's really stupid and short sited to judge it. Look at piercings tattoo's fifteen years agoo these things were not accepted at all. Nowadays they're quite normal. What about pants. hundred years ago they weren't accepted for women. Now they are.

Jon