My guy shouldn't be prettier than me.

Hate hate hate guyliner..let the woman wear makeup!

It reminds me of the punk era kinda like Robert Smith

I don't understand why a man would want to wear eyeliner? I think they look ridiculous. When I think of men with makeup, I think of the early 80s Duran Duran. They wore a lot of makeup.

i don't think he'd really be that attractive if he didn't glam rock himself out.

unless your captain jack sparrow lay off the eyeliner!!!

LOVE 'guylinear' . or , atleast on the guys who suit it . why shouldn't men get to wear make-up ? i draw the line at really heavy make-up (um , marilyn manson ?) but only eyelinear is really hott .

No No NO!! Unless yes, you are Robert Smith, please don't do it!!

the only guy who can pull it off is Captain Jack Sparrow

I agree with Seraphim and Kellylicious! Any other man besides Jack Sparrow looks like a clown with make-up on.

hate it... blah

Yay now i get to vent. Who is the fool who made this and skinny pants cool again. Guyliner does not make you emo, or more metro or whatever the reason guys use it. It's disgusting and I think if a man is wearing makeup anywhere near his eyes he's fruitier than a frigging strawberry banana smoothie and he just doesn't know it yet. I hate guyliner.

I think it's okay for when they're performing, but not for everyday.

^ I'm totally with you nyara! lol

I can't stand guyliner or skinny jeans, they don't look good on anyone! Not even skinny people. Ya look like fools.

def hate it

This doesn't even make men pretty. I already ever wear this much eyeliner or myself.

loooooooove it! i think it's hot! but only certain guys can rock it, not all.... they have to be special!

eww!

I absolutely hate it! It reminds me of how Colin Farrell looked in Alexander. Hated it then and still do!

I don't want to share the wirror with my guy so that his eyeliner is straight

yuck yuck yuck!

Hate it

I LOVE it! I think Pete is fug as hell though

hate it

not a huge fan..ive seen acouple look ok, but you could barely tell they were wearing, still think its wierd...heavy liner like pete def not unless its fancy dress or you're a rockeyr

First of all Robert smith...not punk. Secondly i love eyeliner on guys, but not everyone can pull it off. If its on the wrong person, it looks to contrived. Pete doesnt pull it off.

Gross! I would not date a guy who wears guyliner. I'm all for a man who is in touch with his femininity (metrosexual) but this is too much.

Depends on the guy, and THIS GUY should not be wearing it. Jack Sparrow on the other hand...

I gotta say I like some men with it. I love Johnny Depp with his eyeliner. And I used to like Pete Wentz, pre-Ashley.

I said love it, but really, it depends on the guy. On Johnny Depp? DEFINITELY!

I love it!!!

it really really depends on the guy but i like a man man. if the guy has gorgeous smouldering eyes and manly features then yes

Guy-liner=No.
Peen Wentz is such a douche. I'd like to punch him in the face and give him some permanent eyeliner.
Hehe

Depends on the guy. Rockstars & celebrities, sure; Presidential candidates, not so much.

Hate it! I agree with partysugar....I wouldn't date a guy who wears guyliner!!!!

HATE IT! If he's straight then I don't want him having more make-up than me for sure; if he's not then party on sister.

I love it. Its part of the whole punk look!

No thanks.

I like it on Billy Joe of Greenday but not on Pete Wentz. EWWWW. Yea and on Jack Sparrow too, it looks good.

Uh, no.

i think this is hot. almost all guys i dated rocked the guyliner. just a matter of taste i guess.

It was ok on Scott Weiland because he could pull it off. Pete Wentz just look whack...I can't stand him.

It works for Captain Jack Sparrow - but *only* on Captain Jack Sparrow.

It looks gay on him.

I actually sorta like it, LOL, makes Pete look sexy. Though, not all guys should wear eyeliner and if they do wear it, they should wear it as light as possible.

I think on rockers and people whoare autally celbrities it looks hot, great example, Pete Wentz! but on a regular guy no, they just cant pull it off without looking corny.

I'm an old punk... so I love it!

Depends on the guy. LOVE it on British actor/comedian Russell Brand. Luscious!

It depends on the guy and also how much is applied.

Pete doesn't do a thing for me, but when I've seen photos of guys like Jensen Ackles or Jared Leto when it's just enough to oomph their eyes, then it's great.

So I'm one of the undecided, some guys yes, others oh please stay away from the spackle trowel.

It really depends on the person. Pete Wentz looks great w/ guyliner and so does Gerard Way however I have seen some guys w/ liner on and it does not looks good at all.