I think it's too much for her. She is not the vixen-ish type. A pinkish gloss would have been muuch better.

I agree with LuciLu, it's too much for her. I hope she's not trying to change her image.

I think if she had bigger eyes it might work...it just makes her features swim around in her face. she's so pretty so I think this look just doesn't do her justice

i love how she looks. she looks sexy, but not overtly so...old hollywood glamour. it's so different from her "wholesome" look. i'd love to know what lippie color she's wearing!!

nope, i hate it

LOVE the hair, just wish she'd smile more in this one!!

She can pull off that look but I prefer her sweetie image

i don't really like this look on her but I'm sure she's just trying out something different from her usual goody two shoes look.

i think a slightly lighter lipstick colour would have been better but overall i think she looks hot!

i think she looks good if she's trying out a new look but i hope this isn't THE new look...i like old mandy too!

I think it's nice this one time, but I definitely like her bubbly girly look that she always has. By the way, she has beautiful skin!

I love Mandy Moore but I prefer her natural carefree look. Too much goth not enough vixen. She really does look similar to Jennifer Tilly.

Might look better with a smile.

Eh - not huge on it, but everyone needs to mix it up once in a while, right? Something about this makes her look like a younger Diane Lane to me.

It's not working for me at all.

this IS so a'la' Jennifer Tilly...why mandy? why?

don't like the lip color

I don't see her as a "vixen". The hair looks nice, but the dark lipstick is a bit too much.

This makes her eyes look really small and her face looks puffy. Not working.

not liking the death lips look

her best look is the classy natural look. please dont change your look mandy!!!

I think she looks great. I'm glad she's taking a chance on something new. I find her incredibly boring.

I like everything but the dark lips...

She looks amazing. I like it.

i agree with those who said they like her classy look. its cool that she's trying something different, but i definitely am not a fan of this look. i'm not holding it against her though because at least she made a mistake with lipstick instead of like, getting out of a car and flashing everyone =)

Don't like it. She's a better natural beauty that one that's made up.

She looks too much like Jennifer Tilly...

I didn't even recognize her when I saw the picture. If she's going for the vampish vixen look, she has succeeded.

she's not working it..

I don't like this look on her.

I love it but this is not a good angle for her.

I hate it; she looks better au natural !

She is way to pretty to cover it all up with that dark make up!

I think the dark lipstick makes her mouth look so tiny! I really like her more natural. But maybe this look would have worked if the eye was more smokey and had a lighter lip, sheer gloss or nude.

keep that girl away from garlic!

the dark lipstick is bad, bad, bad.

Hot hot hot!!!

I like it because it's different from what we usually see on her, it's just a shock of surprise. I really was kinda against this year's purpley lipstick, but after seeing it on Mandy, I'm rethinking my opinion. Either way, 20's dark glam Mandy or sweet and soft Mandy, I like both!

That lipstick doesn't suit her at all!

i agree with whomever said it makes her face look puffy. and the dark lipstick makes her top lip look nonexistent.

i love her though! there's nothing wrong with trying a new look, even if it fails

I don't think this is her best look...and I don't think she likes it either, look how uncomfortable she looks!

Honestly, I thought it was and old pic of Drew Barrymore from the 90's at first glance and then was shocked that it was Mandy. I like that she is going against type and trying something new but it was poorly executed.

I think that it's the wrong shade for her and poorly applied --that combined with the weird hair and the Lisa Lisa/Cult Jam bustier makes the look too much.

Love it.

Not so much a fan. I really like Mandy Moore for the fact that she seems so down to earth - you know, the whole inner beauty is just as important as outer beauty cliche. That doesn't I mean I think she can't try to be sexy every now and then, but I just don't think she's going for the right kind of sexy here.

Oh and, McCubcakes, I totally agree - so Jennifer Tilly. It just ain't Mandy.

i really don't like, she tries too hard and her movies are absolute crap.

She looks really uncomfortable. She looks much better with earth tone makeup.

Love the look...but not on her.

It really doesn't work on her

I Hate It!!!

She looks goth, not that that's so bad or anything, but for Mandy...I like her cute, clean-cut look best.