I think it looks a little awkward when he was the makeup on

I voted for with the guy liner, I guess because I'm not used to seeing him without it. It's weird to see him actually looking his age ...

if you imagine him with a shorter haircut in the second one, itd be damn hot.

im gettng so sick of pete looking like all of those other scene bands. fob is not scene and he isnt the main guy in the band. he needs to get over himself. anyway he looks better without all that makeup

I agree with talloolah. It just looks so fobish if he has guyliner on, we don't see Patrick with it on do we? No, we don't. And Pete really does look SO MUCH hotter without the makeup on, even if it does show his age.

He looks SO MUCH BETTER without it!

what a difference that makes without the guyliner!! Keep it off Pete!

I'm more concerned with his hair looking like he dyed it with box color!! He has the money for some professional help.

looks better without

hmm.... better without. strange it's like watching a girl without make up. u know, the bare face etc. hahaha.... i am OK both ways.

Without! He looks so pale with guyliner.

I like both however without eyeliner he looks really hot!

Without. Of course!

Don't like guys that are prettier than me

He actually looks like a man without the guyliner...he could possibly be hot if he got rid of that girlie haircut.

i've never thought i'd say this, but.. with eyeliner.. he looks better, not that pale as he looks without wearing it.

i'm shocking myself saying this- with.

He looks gay without it. Which is a fine look if you want to.

He looks ugly regardless.

without

Without eyeliner, without eyeliner, without eyeliner!!

Hopefully Jared Leto is paying attention (he reads PopSugar, right?)

Uh, yeah. I prefer my men sans make-up, thank you very much. Though this guy would never hit my radar screen, with or without cosmetics.

He actually looks so cute without that eyeliner

I actually like the guyliner now that I've seen without.

without. for the first time, he doesn't look half-bad to me. usually i think he's ugly and now i see it might be the guyliner that makes him look so bad

He has a Sh&tload of OTHER make-up on in picture #2!

how about I prefer him NOT AT ALL

The guyliner's kewl, but what's with being powdered to within an inch of his life? No man needs THAT much foundation, do they?

She looks SEXY without it! Keep it off!

He's repulsive to me no matter what.

without

Wow. He's actually really hot without it!

He should get rid of the foundation also! Yikes!

I'm not gonna lie... Normally, I'm a fan of the guyliner. I guess I just don't like his. Come to think of it... I don't find him attractive at all.

i'm a fan of the guyliner haha

i hate him so he can do whatever he wants if he thinks he looks better with guyliner ...

He needs to give up the fake man-tan and full-on makeup in picture #2. At least in picture #1, the only makeup he looks like he's wearing is guyliner, not foundation, blush, bronzer, etc like #2. Barf! Guys aren't supposed to look peachy and glowy.

I hate to say this, but in picture #2 his makeup resembles that of a corpse. Seriously TOO much. Based upon that, I'm going to have to say he looks better with eyeliner, because at least in the first picture that is the only makeup he has on.

Guyliner? LOL

Yawn for goth.

He is way too pretty either way.

Guyliner to me does not exist- it's plain old women's eyeliner, no fancy names and it's ceepy.

*creepy

he looks much much hotter without the guyliner

without definitely! He looks pale and creepy with the liner!

wow...i'm.....uhhh....speech....less......

without... but I don't like me either way really

He's got beautiful eyes... I saw a picture of him and Ashley Simpson together recently...and their eye makeup was exactly the same!!!

With a cut and refresh of color (black is way too harsh for him) he'd look so much better.

does the guy know that eighties are over ?

Oh my gosh. He's actually attractive! I can hardly believe it.

Now all he needs is a shorter haircut and he'd be almost dead sexy..