I like both, actually.

Heidi!

definitely heidi. her hair looks like it is meant to be there, while kate's just looks like its falling out of place.

i agree; heidi's is much more effortless. i thought kate looked off.

yuck! Def. Kate Walsh. I think I may be giving her extra points just because her makeup is amazing.

I don't like this "do," though I do think Heidi wore it better. Really the prettiest updo's on the red carpet seem to have been worn by Katherine Heigel and America Ferrera. They looked gorgeous! Also, I like Heidi with a little bit less makeup. Her looks lend themselves to "less is more."

neither. they both look so old here. wrinkles, yuck.

I am not a fan of either but Heidi blew me away. By far she was the most stunning of the evening. Not just between these 2 but out of everyone. Go mama!

Heidi wins anything! She's just stunning!

I do not care much for either woman or their hair style but I choose Kate. Kate wore it better. Kates actually looks fixed and Heidi looks like she just threw hers up. Heidi is over rated and I think people are brain washed to say only nice things about her because looking at her hair, it looks like a frizzy, dried out rats nest. Sorry just my opinion.

I think they both look so gorgeous

Heidi

Heidi's looks much nicer

They both look great

BOTH

i dont like this 'do either but yeah heidi's hair looked better, imo

I chose undecided but really would have rather chosen neither. I do not this look at all. Yuck.

*do not like* >.>

i just dont "get" kate's appeal. i don't think she's remotely pretty....but i guess to each his/her own..

Heidi looks amazing!!!

Neither. I think Kate Walsh looked terrible & cheap.

Heidi's.

Heidi

Kate's looked like it wanted to unravel.

I love both of them SO much - but neither of them pulled the hair off. I so wanted to like it - but no no no.

Heidi.

kate walsh. heidi's looks like a donald trump comb over. it covers way too much of her face, and looks strangley thick and teased. and kates makeup is downright gorgeous

"a donald trump comb over"
LMFAO

Don't like this 'do too much, but Heidi's looks a tad better.

I don't like this hairdo on either of them. It kind of has a 'bird's nest' look to it. I think Kate's looks more sleek and pulled together, though.

Neither, they look so untidy. They both need a comb!

i don't like it, but if i had to choose I'd go with Heidi

both look nice

i picked kate's because it looks less frizzy than heidi's and i know this has nothing to do with the hair but heidi's lipstick clashes with her dress. kate's lipstick is spot on.

heidi

Definitely Heidi - Kate looks like she ran out of time.

Kate. I like the lipstick better, Heidi's is too orange. The hair is a look I'm not a big fan of.

heidi's just hung better.

heidi's just was... better.

I like both of them...but Heidi's just a little bit more!

I like the hair on both! I wish Kate's side piece were shorter, that's why I think Heidi's looks so great. I think it looks fresh and new and just fabulous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Its Heidi Klum! She's going to look better than anyone you put her up against! Hands down!

I think both look kind of silly, but Kate's is more polished. Heidi's looks like a true bird's nest. Either she did it herself or a stylist did it and then her kids got to it! She looks beautiful b/c she is, but the hair is a bit of a mess!

I hate the hair on both of them!!! And I don't love either's makeup or jewelry.

i like heidi's better only because i think the front part on kate's is too long.

as for the look itself, i think it's cool that they tried "different" looks.

Heidi. but Kate looks good too!

KATE!!!!! I thought she stole the entire show in that red dress that hit her in all the right places with her side swept red hair, make up, jewels OH MY!!

I don't really like either...

Heidi can pull anything off!

I love this style!