In high school, my friend Marcy had a summertime job at an ice cream shop. From May to October, she'd make countless hot fudge sundaes, remove waffle cones from their iron, and scoop enough ice cream that she had to wear a wrist brace. It was a tough job, but one perk was that when her shift ended, she always smelled amazing: sugary but not cloying, and very soft and fresh.

That's exactly the scent of FarmHouse Fresh Sweet Cream Body Milk ($26), a lightweight body moisturizer. It's a simple, clean, light scent that's not overly foody. Even though it's not thick or heavy, I found that it moisturizes well; this is because it has jojoba, sweet almond, avocado, and sesame oils. Plus, how cute is the glass cruet that it comes in? Each time I use it, I feel like a luxurious dairy farmer—which, if you smell this stuff, will no longer seem like an oxymoron.