Both Eva Mendes and Katie Holmes looked positively lovely yesterday. Katie was making the rounds to talk about Mad Money, while Eva was in Paris to promote her latest project, Live!. Both women look lovely in different ways: Katie's the sophisticate, while Eva has a pretty/sexy thing going on.

So, for a fun change of pace, let's try something new: Tell me whose look you love, and at the end of the day, I'll post a makeup tutorial for whichever look wins more votes. Call it democracy in action to honor the launch of CitizenSugar!

















Casadei
Topman
Maison Martin Margiela
Eva looks gorgeous, but she and I have totally different coloring. So personally, I'd rather see Katie's!
1I love Katie's makeup.She always looks beautiful.
2Katie looks great...
3I have more Katie's complextion.
4I like both...but have Eva's complexion
5I like Katie's makeup.
6eva does look gorgeous, but i can figure out what to do with a little tinted moisturizer, cream blush, and mascara. now katie's eyes... that's a better how to.
7I can't believe that many favored Katie Holmes make-up. Her make-up made her years older. She looked 40 here with this make-up.
I like Eva's make-up better because it's natural and semi-nude except that her eyes are accentuated . Her eyes are defined and the rest of the face are kept barely minimum. Unlike the make-up of Katie, which was uneven.
Katie Holmes make-up don't even match. Her foundation is too "stark" on her face and look at her neck----there's no foundation there. It's uneven. And the blush makes her too skinny and too reddish as if she was punched in the cheeks.
8Eva
9I'd like to see Katie's. Eva's make-up is kinda bland to me.
10I can do Katie's makeup - what I'm wearing right now looks pretty much the same. So ... Eva's makeup, please
11I want Eva's! Her coloring matches mine and I like her style better.
12I'm all about Katie these days!
13I love them both, but I'm closer to Eva's complexion. I usually wear my makeup more like Katie's anyway, so I'd love to try something new.
14That's a tough one for me, because I actually like both looks!
15I'm so jealous of everyone who has Eva's skintone! I would love to have her colouring.
16Eva!
17She is pretty!
For right at this moment since it is winter I am LOVING Katies look because it is simple and elegant - especially the eyes! I also love Eva's look for Spring and Summer.
18Eva has a natural look rather then Katie, that look is what like the most.
19What fun! I love that you're letting us vote, even if my vote is losing. My boyfriend loves him some Eva Mendes so that one would really benefit me. Just a bit of makeup and I could look just like Eva. Right?
20I prefer Katie's makeup, but its the same look I wear almost everyday or everytime I go out, there's nothing different or difficult about it. Eva is also kind of casual and she's more my coloring, but I just don't find anything interesting about it.
21I love Eva's makeup, but I couldn't pull it off with this fair skin.
22Eva! I don't want to look like a 40 year old Stepford wife, thanks.
23I love how Eva looks and being an Olive Skinned girl as well would love the tips....She is stunning...
24miss mendes looks like she ran a marathon by the look of her face.
25Eva; I have fair skin so I would like to get a slight glow. Besides Eva's look is fresh and young.
26I am more like Katie
27I agree with bingkaycoy, I think Katie's makeup and hair have made her look way older than she is. I always go for the more youthful look.
28i've been loving Katie's look lately. smart and sophisticated!
29I love Katie's eyes!
30I just want to know how her skin is so matte?
31GO KATIE GO
32Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.