Alicia Keys at the 2009 MTV VMAs

Alicia Keys always looks ineffably cool. Like so many other celebrities, she opted for a big, bold updo. Instead of the white eye shadow we've been seeing all over the red carpet tonight, though, she went for a flattering gunmetal-gray and silver combination that's less harsh than straight-out white. A little blush and a neutral pink lip kept her from looking washed out. What do you think? Is this look a symphony of subtle shades, or an off-note?

Vote on all of my MTV VMAs polls here!