Amanda Bynes at the 2009 MTV VMAs

I'm so used to seeing Amanda as the girl next door that this sultry look was a real shocker. Between the dramatic eyelashes, white eye shadow, and the distinctly puffed pout, I didn't recognize her at first. Her big, perfect curls are a red carpet staple no matter what look she's rocking, but I'm wondering — are you ready to see Amanda as a va-va-voom sexpot, or do you want her to stick to her usual America's sweetheart look?

Vote on all of my MTV VMAs polls here!