i think she looks sexier blonde!! for sure

I can't decide!

i think if she curled the brunette hair they'd be even. but straight brown hair makes it look kind of flat.

She looks sexier in blonde , but there are so many lost and dumb blonde celebrities these days ---Paris, Jessica and Britney.

I'm kind of sick of blonde hair. It looks really good on her but I just find she blends in with it, i liked her more with light brown hair. Besides I don't know if its her make up person or what but I think ever since we've seen her blonde she's lokked kind of pageanty (in her face only). Or is it just me?

I like both, but miss her natural light brown hair. In those photos she looks better blonde. I think I don't like her dark brown hair when she's tan.

blonde, but she's a cutie both ways

She looks really great both ways, but I seem to like her as a blonde much better. It just matches her bubbly personality, facial features, and smile!

Blonde, it looks more natural.

I think she looks good with both hair colors but I definetly like the brunette better.

she looks good with either. I just wish she'd stop wearing her hair straight around her face. I don't think it works for her.

She looks great with both. I'm not sure though, something about that blond hair looks Lindsay Lohan-ish on her.

I think she is much prettier as a brunette, but not in these two pictures... Here she is prettier blonde. You could have chosen a better brunette pic as a comparison

I think she looks much better blonde, but maybe it is the brunette look with the straight hair plastered to her face that I don't like.

i dun like her

Brunette. The blonde is so trashy looking.

I liked her when she was like a honey blonde color on "what I like about you" and when her face was a little thinner than it is in either of these pics.. cheeks are kinda chub here which is kinda out of place with her thin bod

it looks healthier blonde

She's pretty either way, but the blond does look a bit better.

oh yea and she used to do her hair with a nice spiral wave to it.. much much cuter

The blonde hair looks great on her. I liked her as a light brunette better than the darker brown since the dark seems harsh on her. However she is really looking great as a blonde.

hard choice id say both but maybe the blonde stands out more on her

I think she looks pretty either way!

The blonde brightens up her face.

i liked the dirty blond circa what i like about you. miss that show i'm glad she has apple cheecks- she's still adorable.

i liked the dirty blond circa what i like about you. miss that show i'm glad she has apple cheecks- she's still adorable.

i like it in the blonde above. but it actually looks like a nice shade of caramel which does suit her very well. very blonde would not work at all IMO.

As she was in She's the Man

I do like her as a brunette, partly because she doesn't look so made up and so L.A., but it's a close call.

I think I would like her best somewhere in between these two looks...maybe a light brown with some golden hightlights

blonde, but like several people said, i think she looks the best in the middle.

She looks great with both colors; she's a very pretty girl. I picked blonde though because I was more drawn to that picture.

Sugar should have used a better picture of Amanda Bynes with brown hair. She looks so much better with brown hair like when she was in What I Like About You. She had beautiful honey brown hair that was wavy. If they used a picture of her with that hair juxtaposed to her blonde hair, I guarantee that everyone would think brown is so much better!

She would look better with a paper bag over her head.

She looks better as a blonde. I love brunettes but some girls just don't look right with brown hair. She happens to be one of them, unless you prove me wrong with a better picture.

blondeLicious of course~^^

i think is too blonde

i think the blonde hair looks great against her skin, and it makes her eyes really stand out!! amanda bynes is always one of my favorites though, i've been thrilled that she's been everywhere lately because of hairspray!

she looks so pretty either way!

I liked the hair she had on What I Like About You. Like a dirty blonde. The new blonde isn't the same, but I like it better than brunette.

Blonde definitely, she seems more "alive" and youthful.

...shes very pretty now that shes blonde

blonde, she works both looks though

I say Blonde

Her original hair color was beautiful on her. The caramel color worked on her features and skin beautifully.
I still love Amanda though.

i with everyone who says the dirty/caramely highlighted blonde worked best on her. She's too blonde now...and whoa does she wear a lot of makeup!

She's such a doll both ways, but I love the blonde.

I don't like her hair in either of these pictures. The styles really distract from the color. Her hair is way too flat, it's annoying. Her head is huge too

Blonde definitely!
Makes her glow.

usually brunette is so much more flattering on a lot of celebrities (case in point: mandy moore), but amanda always looked better blonde. of course, it doesn't help that her brunette picture isn't all that flattering.