The Best Halloween Nail Colors, According to a Celebrity Manicurist

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

We think it's worth the forewarning that dressing up your nails takes on a completely different meaning once October arrives. With Halloween on the not-too-distant horizon, it's time to shift your Pinterest boards from summery sets to moodier alternatives like the classic french, chrome finishes, and dark and vampy nail-polish hues. While it's conventional to stick with orange when it comes to spooky season, in recent years, Halloween nails have been taken to new heights. Take cues from unofficial nail aficionados like Megan Thee Stallion with her light-up nails or even Kylie Jenner and her black sparkly nails, which are the ultimate Halloween vibe.

To find the most popular — and in some cases, unexpected — Halloween nail colors for the spooky season, we tapped celebrity nail artist Elle Gerstein, who has created looks for Blake Lively and Jessica Chastain, to name just a couple of her A-lister clientele, to weigh in. Check out her picks ahead.

Halloween Nail Colors: Rich Metallics and Duochromes
walmart.com

Halloween Nail Colors: Rich Metallics and Duochromes

Want to play up the mystical feel of Halloween? Try it on your fingers. "Rich, metallic purples and duochrome blues and greens create an unexpected look," Gerstein says.

She named the LeChat Dare to Wear Metallux Nail Polish in Hypnotic ($12) as one of her favorites for its blue-to-green shift.

Halloween Nail Colors: Pumpkin Spice
lechatnails.com

Halloween Nail Colors: Pumpkin Spice

You can't go wrong with a pumpkin hue for Halloween month. Gerstein loves LeChat's Perfect Match Mood polish in Pumpkin Spice (which is available only in salons) for this look. "It transitions from pumpkin orange to a faint caramel shade depending on your body temp [and glows] like a jack-o'-lantern or the eyes of a black cat."

Halloween Nail Colors: Deep Purples
ulta.com

Halloween Nail Colors: Deep Purples

Dark colors are a fall staple. Get the look using the OPI Infinite Shine Long-Wear Nail Polish in Raisin' the Bar ($14), or one of the following nail polishes.

Halloween Nail Colors: Spicy Mustard Yellow
cirquecolors.com

Halloween Nail Colors: Spicy Mustard Yellow

Gerstein named mustard yellow nail polish — like the Cirque Colors Crème Nail Polish in Urbanized ($13) — as another warm option to try during the weeks leading up to Halloween.

Halloween Nail Colors: Red Patent
butterlondon.com

Halloween Nail Colors: Red Patent

Candy-apple-red manicures are both sweet for Halloween and a trend that one expert foresees sticking around through the entire season.

"Red, burgundy, berry — these deep shades are emblematic of fall and represent a sophisticated twist on quintessential bright red nail polish while still being feminine and classic," nail expert and eponymous brand owner Jin Soon Choi previously told POPSUGAR. "They are timeless colors that cross from classic to modern and feminine to bold — making them perfect for all autumn occasions."

Re-create the nail look using the Butter London Come to Bed Red ($18), or one of the following options.