Scarlett's been wearing this smoky cat eye lately, and though it's easy to mess this one up, she's been pulling it off well. The trick to this look is to do the liner before your shadow. Line your upper and lower lids equally thickly, and then pull the line out from beside your eye instead of above or below. Then, using a charcoal or deep plum shadow, make a broad, thick cat eye shape from the center of your lid all the way out to the tips of your eyebrows. Put white shadow in the inner corners of your eyes to open them up, and then blend.