Kate vs. Keira: Who Do You Prefer as the Face of Chanel's Fragrance?

May 21, 2007

Last year, Chanel announced it was ditching Kate Moss for Keira Knightley as the face of its Coco Mademoiselle fragrance. Keira's ads have just started to run in France, so tell me which model you prefer.

Source and Source

71 Comments

blondey 4 years

Definitely Kate. She looks much more haute - and THAT is Chanel. :makeup:

katie_c 5 years

not a keira knightley fan at all and i hated when i started seeing her all over my fragrance. love kate moss.

peachiepink 5 years

kate is definitely much more elegant looking. keira looks a tad juvenile in the ad.

pumachick100 5 years

Keira is the better one.

pumachick100 5 years

Keira is the better one.

factorybabe 5 years

KATE of course, kate is so much more coco mademoiselle than keira, she's a sophisticated bad girl and she's just prettier than keira, i think that kate is the only person that actually looks great being skinny, she makes it look beautiful

aseret 6 years

My vote is for Keira.She has the class that is Chanel.

strawberry mac 6 years

I'm not a huge Kate Moss fan, but I love that ad.

JaimeLeah526 6 years

I do not like Kate Moss at all and especially in this Ad. What is with the hairdo? Keira is probably not the right choice either but she's way better than Kate.

VIOLHAINE 6 years

I thought (once again) it was Natalie Portman on the left, so I was like "Cool! I'm gonna vote for her!"...But then I realized, so I voted "neither".

VIOLHAINE 6 years

I thought (once again) it was Natalie Portman on the left, so I was like "Cool! I'm gonna vote for her!"... But then I realized, so I voted "neither".

viridiana 6 years

And its my perfume!!!!!

viridiana 6 years

And its my perfume!!!!!

viridiana 6 years

Keira looks a lot like Shalom Harlow in her early stages, she is just sooooo plain and tooo skinny. I ll always go for Kate... she has that dirty side, that exudes perfection!!!! LOVE KATE MOSS!

viridiana 6 years

Keira looks a lot like Shalom Harlow in her early stages, she is just sooooo plain and tooo skinny. I ll always go for Kate... she has that dirty side, that exudes perfection!!!! LOVE KATE MOSS!

chatoyante 6 years

They both look emaciated. Gross.

Annabean 6 years

I'm not a fan of either, but if I had to choose, I would choose Keira over Kate, for sure!

heysailor 6 years

Channel is meant to be classic/classy. There isn't much classy about coke binges. Keira would win out of the two, but I'm not a fan of the layout.

gruaig_rua 6 years

So sick of Kate! :SICK:

gruaig_rua 6 years

So sick of Kate! :SICK:

MisterPinkNoTip 6 years

I completely agree Junebrug!Yeah, Marilyn Monroe was Channel, but as far as modern models go, I'll have to say Nicole did a better job than these two.

MisterPinkNoTip 6 years

I completely agree Junebrug! Yeah, Marilyn Monroe was Channel, but as far as modern models go, I'll have to say Nicole did a better job than these two.