There are some celebrities who you expect to show up with out-of-the-box makeup looks, and then there are celebrities like Keira Knightley [1], who tends to stick to a simple makeup palette. So imagine our surprise when the actress stepped out for the LA premiere of Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit, with a dramatic smoky eye. Her shadow had a blue base — Chanel Le Crayon Khol Intense Eye Pencil in Marine [2] ($28) — that clung closely to her eyes, but diffused out into a sultry navy shade —Chanel Illusion D'Ombre Long Wear Luminous Eye Shadow in Apparition [3] ($36)— extending to the inner corners of her eyes. To keep attention on her colorful eye palette, Keira kept the rest of her look simple: matte, nude lips, and luminous skin. We love to see a star like Keira get a little creative with her eye makeup, but what do you think?