Pictures of Drew Barrymore and Hayden Panettiere Looking Alike at the 2009 Emmys

Whose Wavy Updo/Red Lip Combo Looked Better at the Emmys?

September 21, 2009

The similarities between Drew Barrymore and Hayden Panettiere's hair and makeup last night were shockingly similar, and judging by the comments you made for both Drew and Hayden in my love it or hate it polls, you noticed it, too. Besides the heavier-handed makeup application and the addition of a darker liner on Hayden, the two blond actresses could have passed for sisters or long-lost relatives with their matchy-matchy wavy updos and red lips. Even their eye colors and bronzy eye shadow shades bear a strong resemblance. But if you had to choose, which Emmy-goer gets your vote?

Source: WireImage

23 Comments

3 years 24 weeks

Well i am not surprised that Drew got so many votes because she is just fabulous and i feel like that she is now been among the best actresses ,and she is looking so gorgeous in this pick.replica bag

Jen Erate 3 years 27 weeks

I am surprised that so many more people voted for Drew. hayden lip colour is just a little more vibrant but it makes a world of difference for me

lovesickblues111 3 years 31 weeks

The red looks fabulous on Hayden, but she looks like she washed her face in make-up... Drew knows how to make-up better.

POPSUGAR Beauty 3 years 35 weeks

I do know that Drew brought CoverGirl Outlast Lipstain in Berry Smooch ($8) with her for touchups!

POPSUGAR Beauty 3 years 35 weeks

I do know that Drew brought CoverGirl Outlast Lipstain in Berry Smooch ($8) with her for touchups!

3 years 35 weeks

Hayden does have the advantage, being young and gorgeous, but she looks too overdone. Everything from her penciled in eyebrows to using three shades of lipstick to make them look fuller (and the lipliner is a bit too stark) to the thick foundation just ruins what could have been a lovely look. I do like how she did the eyes, though - the white liner on the lower lid really opens up the eye, and her lashes look lovely.

coruscate7 3 years 35 weeks

It's not fair. I love them both.

cupcake_ 3 years 35 weeks

I like Drew's look better.

cupcake_ 3 years 35 weeks

I like Drew's look better.

Florida Snow 3 years 35 weeks

This was a close one, they're both stunning, but Hayden just looks too "done." Drew's a little more natural, more glowy.

blossommac 3 years 35 weeks

Hayden to much tan drew so cute

blossommac 3 years 35 weeks

Hayden to much tandrew so cute

tellmemorex2 3 years 35 weeks

Drew's, but I really dont like either look.

mwmsjuly19 3 years 35 weeks

Drew! So fresh and pretty. They spackled Hayden with foundation, for Pete's sake.

genesisrocks 3 years 35 weeks

Drew looks completely effortless in comparison to Hayden, who looks like she tried too hard

3 years 35 weeks

Drew looks stunning. I'd love to know what foundation and products she used - she's glowing. I love her green eyes too! :) Hayden looks like she's 15 years older for sure....

JaimeLeah526 3 years 35 weeks

Drew looks much more natural her skin really shines through and she looks fantastic. Hayden has too much foundation and bronzer on and she's got fabulous skin that she shouldn't be hiding under all that makeup. Honestly Hayden's hair looks better from the front but Drew's is much cooler in the back.

JaimeLeah526 3 years 35 weeks

chelseacbboyles 3 years 35 weeks

I like Drew's better because when you do a red lip that bold the rest of the makeup should be more understated but Hayden has intense makeup all around...

esweet 3 years 35 weeks

Agreed, there is probably a 15 year age-difference between the two and Drew looks younger!