With her fair coloring, it makes perfect sense that Scarlett would go for a bright, high-contrast red to pick up her pretty pink undertones and alabaster skin.
Julia's Soft Strawberry Blond
Julia Roberts made a return to a light strawberry after spending some time with dark auburn hair. Going back to a red-tinged shade closer to her natural dark-blond color was a smart way to get back to her literal roots and get a boost of pretty titian color.
Blake's Comely Carrot
Blake Lively's decision to go red was perhaps the most surprising of the bunch, but she's made it work by choosing a copper shade and wearing cool colors like seafoam.
Drew's Rich Red
Drew Barrymore decided to play up her hazel eyes and cute freckles with a lovely rich auburn. Auburn is a good choice for people who want a natural-looking red, since it has enough brown in it and enough depth of color to look like you were born with it.