You'd think that a staple like this one would be overwhelmingly adored. But, it's actually quite the opposite, receiving a 2.5 rating. Maybelline's Great Lash Waterproof Mascara ($4.50) definitely has its fans, but some people are disappointed in this product's results.
One reader loves her Great Lash. She quipped, "Every now and then I'll buy a different kind of mascara just to see if I like it better, and none have made my eye lashes look so full and long and smudge-proof as Great Lash." Another reader is not feeling the hype. She states, "It's too wet, takes forever to dry, and then when it does dry, it flakes. No thanks."