Vote For the Best Mascaras of 2009

Best of 2009: Mascaras

December 7, 2009

I don't know what I would do without mascara — it's the product that makes the biggest difference in my look, and a couple of quick coats are guaranteed to make anyone feel more bright-eyed. After a lot of trial and error, I've gotten my list down to a favorite few products, but which brand do you think makes the best lash enhancer?

72 Comments

AprilEverlong 2 years 47 weeks

I'm #4 that is for Bare Essentials Buxom mascara. This is an AWESOME mascara. I've heard DiorShow is great but I can't bring myself to switch...and I'm super doubtful now from these reviews. If you haven't tried Buxom, you should. It seriously makes your eyelashes look like Double-Ds. :)

lemonchunk 2 years 48 weeks

I really like the Bourjois Volume Clubbing mascara :)

3 years 4 weeks

By Apple Super Lash mascara!

SimplyGunaaa 3 years 12 weeks

Bare Essentuals Buxom Lash Best mascara ever! A quick swipe for defined and lengthed but natural lashes. It's so buildable

SimplyGunaaa 3 years 12 weeks

Bare Essentuals Buxom Lash Best mascara ever! A quick swipe for defined and lengthed but natural lashes. It's so buildable

dani19 3 years 22 weeks

what about yves saint laurent! its the besttttttT

love_mimsx3 3 years 22 weeks

i freakin love mascara! but i'm all about the drugstore brands...covergirl lashblast, maybelline stilleto, maybelline the colossal, and max factor 2000 calories are currently in my makeup bag.

aimeelove 3 years 23 weeks

I haven't tried all of these, but I regularly use CoverGirl LashBlast, and I really like it.

ThePerfectScore 3 years 23 weeks

Dior show iconic !

ThePerfectScore 3 years 23 weeks

Dior show iconic !

Nyxish 3 years 23 weeks

I agree that DiorShow is overrated. I've been using L'Oreal Voluminous mascara.

3 years 23 weeks

ARMANI EYES TO KILL --- best mascara ever! Period.

xMiss Worldx 3 years 23 weeks

Makeup For Ever's Smoky Lash workes well for me.. used to love Lancom but for some weird reason it gives me allergies.

chelseacbboyles 3 years 23 weeks

I'm surprised no one has mentioned Bare Escentuals Buxom Lash Mascara. THIS IS AMAZING! Maybe it hasn't built up enough hype yet because it is a new product that they carry but I first got it as a sample at Sephora and I have not turned back! As a side note you might like to know that I switched from Diorshow Mascara to Bare Escenuals Buxom Lash. And this may sound picky but it is a GREAT bottom lash mascara.

hebrew hunny 3 years 23 weeks

Chanel Inimitable

hebrew hunny 3 years 23 weeks

Chanel Inimitable

trendyindc 3 years 23 weeks

MAC Zoom Lash with their primer = super long curly lashes. I take an old clean wand and wiggle through after the second application so you avoid the scary gunk. I have had more people compliment my lashes since I've used this combo then ever in my life. They end up touching my sunglasses.

Yogaforlife 3 years 23 weeks

I used to love Lancome's Magnificels but I can't find that anymore. After trying clinique, Estee Lauder, Maybelline, Cover Girl, Loreal, I've finally settled on Rimmel. For some reason it's the only one that makes my lashes look fuller without clumping.

3 years 23 weeks

I'm actually really impressed by Bare Escentuals Buxom mascara - it "hugs" your lashes as you apply it and coats and separates easily. I do love DiorShow and Clinique High Impact. You can't beat Lancome Deneficil though - it keeps your lashes soft all day and you can apply multiple times without your lashes feeling hard and crusty.

jenni5 3 years 23 weeks

Loreal Featherlash - cheap and works great!!! The Maybelline with the vibrating brush is good too.

3 years 23 weeks

Tarte- Lash Hugger!

clippershipcapt 3 years 23 weeks

I'm a firm believer in DiorShow. I have freakishly long eyelashes to begin with so it creates the prefect drama and the large brush is wonderful-- on dance team in high school I never had to wear fake eyelashes! I don't think I'll every stray from this mascara.

bittie 3 years 23 weeks

agree diorshow somewhat overrated. my unexpected secret weapon is almay triple effect. thickens, lengthens, and opens the eye. people constantly ask if my lashes are real when i'm wearing it.

rivekkah 3 years 23 weeks

I luhrve YSL!

rivekkah 3 years 23 weeks

I luhrve YSL!

Link Love

72 Comments

You Might Also Like